Hannibal Free Public Library

Fates and Traitors

Jennifer Chiaverini

January 21, 2019
2:30 – 4:00 p.m.


Discussion Questions

1.)What do you think of the author’s choice to begin the story with John Wilkes Booth’s death and end it with  Lucy’s point of view? Did this authorial choice make the assassin’s story more poignant for you?

2.) What do you think of Junius’s unconventional views on marriage as “lifelong enslavement” and an “iron yoke that crushes all who submit to it”? How does this compare to his abolitionist views?

3.) When Junius decides to elope to America with MaryAnn, he tells her that “Americans are individualists ,tolerant and free-thinking. They wouldn’t care.” How has this view of Americans withstood the test of time?

4.) While Junius spirals into alcoholism, Mary Ann feels she might “burst from the strain of repressing her anger and disappointment. . . . She would not become a shrew, complaining and criticizing . . . Their home must remain his safe haven, free of judgment and recriminations, or he might grow despondent and decide not to return to it.” Discuss the roles of wives during the early nineteenth century.

5.) Why do you think Mary Ann destroys Junius’s  letters?  What about them makes her want to destroy these personal relics from her husband’s past?

6.) John is heavily inspired by his father’s writings that “fame and glory are marvelous prizes.” How does John change after the death of his father, the strongest advocate of abolitionism he had known, while he became a Confederate sympathizer? Was there always a potential for John to follow the path he chose, or would things have been different had his father, and his influence, not died prematurely?

7.) Introverted and meek Edwin becomes a legendary stage actor by accident whereas Booth eagerly strives to become one. Booth also often finds himself overshadowed and at odds with Edwin. Compare and contrast the two brothers, their personalities, acting careers, and political beliefs.

8.) Booth is strongly against Asia’s marrying Clarke. Why do you think he was so protective of his younger sister?  Do you think his misgivings were later found to be true? Why or why not?

9.) What other options did Asia have aside from marrying Clarke? Discuss the role of young women in society during the mid-nineteenth century society

     10.) Booth sympathized with the character of Brutus from Julius Caesar. How do you think Booth’s love of theater and drama influenced, if at all, his decision to assassinate Lincoln?

11.) Compare and contrast the lives and hardships of widows Mary Ann Booth and Mary Surratt an


Adapted from:  https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/books/314683/        fates-and-traitors-by-jennifer-chiaverini/9781101983843/readers-guide/